Motor Finance Redress: Update November 2026
The motor finance redress scheme was designed to be more manageable for lenders than fighting millions of individual complaints, however with the legal challenges to the Financial Conduct Authority’s compensation scheme due to complete in March of next year, lenders and brokers need to prepare for more than one possible outcome.
We now know that the Upper Tribunal is scheduled to hear the legal challenges between 16 February and 3 March 2027. Firms, however, shouldn’t put their preparations on hold and the FCA has been clear that, despite the partial suspension of the scheme, a number of regulatory obligations remain in force.
The FCA have continued to publish guidance and updates to support affected firms, but this has left a huge amount of information for firms to trawl through, understand, and action in a relatively short space of time, all while knowing they could be faced with settling thousands of complaints before summer next year.
Understanding the current position
The FCA’s Motor Finance Consumer Redress Scheme (CONRED) was introduced to try to structure a common approach to compensating customers who had been treated unfairly through specific, historic, commission arrangements.
However, following the legal challenges, parts of the scheme were suspended by an Upper Tribunal order in July 2026.
This partial suspension means that firms are not currently required to calculate or pay compensation, or issue communications about compensation owed under the scheme timetable, until the legal process concludes.
Importantly, this is not a wholesale suspension of firms’ responsibilities. The FCA expects firms to continue complying with the CONRED requirements that remain in force, while also preparing for the possibility that the scheme, or parts of it, may be overturned.
The FCA is doing what they can, but inevitably this leaves firms with a difficult balancing act. They need to maintain operational readiness without investing unnecessary time and resource in processes that might need to change.
What should firms be doing now?
There are several practical areas that lenders and brokers should be reviewing in the months leading up to the hearing:
1. Review your complaints handling arrangements. The partial suspension does not mean that all motor finance complaints can be put on hold. Firms should continue identifying relevant complaints and agreements, and respond to consumers who are not entitled to compensation under the scheme where the relevant requirements apply. Complaints involving issues outside of the scope of CONRED must also be progressed through the usual process.
2. Check the quality and availability of historic data. This is repeated again and again by the FCA in their guidance: firms should be confident that they can access the information needed to assess agreements, including records held by other parties. For brokers, this includes responding to lenders’ requests for information, or confirming that the information is not held, within one month of the request. Incomplete records and difficulties retrieving information can all create delays when complaint volumes increase. Thinking about these issues now could save considerable time and resource later.
3. Review customer communications. The current position is difficult enough for firms to understand, customers understandably will be confused and frustrated. The FCA expects lenders to keep complainants informed about the legal challenge, the partial suspension and the likely impact on complaint handling and compensation times.
Check your communications are clear and accurate. The aim is to make sure that customers understand what is happening, what the firm is doing, and what they can expect next.
4. Consider contingency arrangements. At this point, firms need to think about what will happen if the Tribunal does not uphold the FCA’s scheme. The FCA has made it clear that its planning assumption is that if the scheme or parts of it are quashed, there may be no compensation scheme and no complaints handling pause. In that situation, lenders would need to be ready to manage the usual complaint-led and supervisory approach, including the relevant statutory complaint handling timescales.
This means considering whether existing complaints systems, resources, management information and governance arrangements would be able to cope with a potentially significant increase in complaint activity. The FCA has also highlighted the importance of financial resilience, appropriate provisions and engagement with auditors.
A contingency plan should be more than a statement that the firm will wait for the Tribunal’s decision.
Is your complaints review process ready?
The period leading up to February provides a real opportunity to look at the effectiveness of existing complaints handling arrangements and consider whether current processes are producing fair, consistent and well-evidenced outcomes.
A complaints review process can help identify potential weaknesses before complaint volumes increase or regulatory scrutiny intensifies. Importantly a review should look beyond whether individual complaints have been processed correctly. It should also consider whether the firm’s overall process is robust, repeatable and capable of handling increased demand.
Keeping up with further developments
The motor finance redress landscape remains subject to change. The Tribunal hearing will be a major milestone, but firms should also be prepared for further FCA communications, guidance and potential changes to implementation arrangements.
Keeping track of these changes can be particularly challenging for smaller firms, where regulatory responsibilities are often managed alongside day-to-day work. This is where a bespoke regulatory update can be valuable. Rather than relying on general headlines, firms need to understand what developments mean for their own business.
We can help. A bespoke regulatory update, curated by our in-house experts gives your firm’s Senior Management a clear view of what’s changing and what’s coming next. Instead of reacting to reforms once they’re finalised, our detailed document enables financial services firms to gain an early understanding of the themes, proposals and supervisory priorities most relevant to their activities.
Contact Robert Bell to find out more.








Comments